Tobacco Stocks May Be Volatile But Remain Good Credit Risks

Tobacco stocks dropped sharply last week after Philip Morris reported declining sales volumes and disappointing results from recent investments in “healthier” nicotine delivery systems.

Big Tobacco is at a crossroads, and recent share price drops show how nervous investors are about the outlook for this sector. But Tobacco still has some advantages: profit margins benefit from a ban on advertising, production requires limited investment, and regulation discourages new entrants.

Governments have a conflict of interest where tobacco regulation is concerned; for example, some estimates suggest that UK smokers contribute £4 for every £1 that they cost the NHS. There are 1 billion smokers globally – 13% of the world’s population. And while smoking is in decline across the developed world, the proportion of smokers is increasing in a number of developing countries, especially in Africa and the Middle East.

Tobacco remains cash generative and – according to research by Dimson, Marsh and Staunton – has been the best performing US equity sector since 1900. But the challenge of transforming that cash into productive investment remains. New nicotine delivery technologies – such as vaping – were initially seen as a competitive threat, but became the new hope for a high margin growth opportunity. However, vaping has brought few new users; most vapers are former smokers.

Some investors hope that the increasing legalization of cannabis provides an opportunity to rejuvenate the sector, but there are various regulatory, political and cultural obstacles to marijuana directly replacing tobacco as a major revenue stream.

Bank-sourced data shows that most tobacco companies are viewed as stable investment grade obligors. The chart shows the credit distribution for 10 tobacco parent companies or subsidiaries (only some of these are quoted). Most of these have a CBC* of bbb or better and 2 of them have a CBC of a; just two of these companies are below investment grade. Tobacco companies may be a volatile equity investment, but they are good credit risks.

*Credit Benchmark Consensus (“CBC”): this is a 21-category alphanumeric scale based on bank-sourced one-year probability of default estimates.  It is similar to the scale used by the main credit rating agencies, so that a CBC of bbb is approximately equivalent to BBB reported by S&P and Fitch, and Baa2 reported by Moody’s

Follow us on:

Credit Benchmark brings together internal credit risk views from over 40 leading global financial institutions. The contributions are anonymized, aggregated, and published in the form of consensus ratings and aggregate analytics to provide an independent, real-world perspective of credit risk. Risk and investment professionals at banks, insurance companies, asset managers and other financial firms use the data for insights into the unrated, monitoring and alerting within their portfolios, benchmarking, assessing and analyzing trends, and fulfilling regulatory requirements and capital.